Running a business can be exciting, fulfilling work, especially when working with partners who share the same vision and goals for your enterprise. While the entrepreneurial spirit is important for running a successful business, so is being prepared for when business-related disputes inevitably arise.
You may be on the best of terms with your partner(s), but if a dispute arises that could potentially grind your business to a halt, it’s important to have a dispute resolution plan in order to avoid costly litigation and the potential dissolution of your business.
What Causes Business Partner Disputes?
Disagreements and disputes are common facts of life–especially when dealing with business partners. Disputes commonly arise out of a number of sources:
- Breach of Fiduciary Duty & Misconduct: When a partner acts contrary to their responsibilities and obligations to the business, per the terms of the partnership agreement or other controlling documents. Under Section 620.8404, Florida Statutes, every business partner owes a duty of loyalty (partners need to prioritize the interests of the business over their own) and a duty of care (partners need to make informed decisions with diligence and good judgment).
- Financial or Profit-Sharing Disputes: Partners may disagree over profit-sharing provisions and distributions, especially if one partner disproportionately contributes to the business over time.
- Management Conflicts: When partners disagree over management powers and responsibilities; where one partner desires more control over day-to-day operations, or alternatively, desires less responsibility than what was initially agreed upon.
- Interpersonal Disagreements: From the clashing of egos, to personal disputes, to simply not liking the other partner’s fashion sense, any sort of interpersonal agreement can negatively affect the professional relationship underlying a business.
Why Not Just Litigate Disputes?
You might believe that if a serious dispute arises in your business relationship, directly pursuing litigation to obtain a judgement against your partners is the fastest, most effective path to resolving problems. While litigation is in fact an option, it’s not as simple as that.
If you have a strong case in your favor, litigation may very well get you the outcome you desire, however, the disputing partner will likely not take it lying down. Litigation can often be a long, drawn-out, arduous process, costing you money, energy, and time away from your business.
Apart from costing potentially tens of thousands of dollars in attorney fees and costs (not to mention any judgments entered against you), if it is determined that you and your business partner are at a genuine impasse where the business cannot be properly run as is, the court may order a judicial dissolution of the business. Not only would you be left with debt, but also the potential loss of your business. With all this considered, litigation should be viewed as a last resort to resolving serious partnership disputes.
So let’s look at some alternatives to litigation that could save you time, money, and your business.
Alternatives to Save Time, Money, and Your Business
Negotiation
The most informal and readily available alternative dispute resolution option is negotiation, where the disputing parties attempt to resolve their disagreements and issues through open, direct communications with one another, and, if desired, with each parties’ attorneys present.
This option is intended for the partners to identify issues and potentially come to mutually agreeable solutions to their problems, without the need of costly litigation. Through negotiation, partners can resolve their disputes through a rehashing of management responsibilities and expectations, a restructuring of their profit-sharing arrangement, or even a partner buyout. However, it is important to note that each negotiation session is dependent upon the specific issues and needs of your business and dispute circumstances, and each party must enter into it with an open, constructive mindset.
Mediation
If negotiations fail, alternative dispute resolution (mediation and arbitration) is always an option, and still much cheaper than litigation.
Mediation occurs by having a neutral third-party mediator facilitating a discussion between the disputing parties by aiding them in exploring options, solutions, and–hopefully–finding some common ground. Unlike in arbitration and litigation, the mediator here cannot order a solution or compromise that the parties must follow; the parties hold total control over deciding whether they want to settle or not.
Arbitration
Arbitration is a more formal option for dispute resolution; it occurs before a neutral arbitrator or arbitration panel whose job it is to review facts, hears arguments from each side, and eventually issue a ruling on the parties and their positions. Unlike mediation, binding arbitration procedures are final and often strip away a party’s right to appeal–whatever the arbitrator or panel decides, is final. Alternatively, non-binding arbitration allows a dissatisfied party (or parties) to request a formal trial in court, where the business dispute will be reviewed from the beginning by a judge or jury. Here is where the litigation begins.
Solutions Tailored for You
Whether you choose to mediate, arbitrate, or enter negotiations with your business partner in an attempt to resolve a dispute, it’s important to speak with an attorney to determine which avenue works best for your specific business needs and situation.